Finance Software RFI: The Ultimate Guide to Vendor Selection

Choosing the right finance software is one of the most critical decisions a modern business can make. The right platform can unlock efficiency, provide strategic insights, and scale with your growth. The wrong one can lead to costly manual workarounds and data silos. This is where a well-crafted Finance Software RFI (Request for Information) becomes your most powerful tool.

An RFI is the crucial first step in your procurement journey. It enables you to survey the market, understand vendor capabilities, and build a solid foundation for a future Request for Proposal (RFP). This guide will walk you through every step of creating a comprehensive RFI that gets you the clear, comparable information needed to make the best choice.

What Is a Finance Software RFI (And Why It Matters)

A Request for Information is a formal document used to gather general information from potential software vendors. Unlike a highly detailed RFP, the purpose of an RFI is exploratory. It helps you:

• Understand the Vendor Landscape: Discover who the key players are and what solutions they offer.
• Compare Capabilities: Get a high-level overview of features, technology, and service models.
• Refine Your Requirements: Use vendor responses to clarify your own business needs and objectives.
• Create a Shortlist: Identify the most promising vendors to invite to the more intensive RFP and demo stages.

By issuing a structured RFI, you streamline the vendor selection process, ensuring you only invest time with providers that genuinely align with your business needs, compliance requirements, and long-term vision.

Laying the Foundation: Before You Write Your RFI

To receive tailored and relevant responses, you must first provide vendors with the right context.

1. Company Overview & Business Context

Begin with a concise snapshot of your organization. This helps vendors understand your operational environment. Include:

• Industry: e.g., SaaS, Manufacturing, Non-profit.
• Company Size: Number of employees and annual revenue figures.
• Operational Structure: Number of legal entities, countries of operation, and currencies managed.
• Existing Tech Stack: Mention your current ERP, CRM, payroll systems, or any legacy finance software.

2. Business Drivers & Strategic Objectives

Clearly articulate why you are seeking new finance software. What pain points are you trying to solve? Common drivers include:

• Improving Reporting: The need for faster, more accurate financial and management reports.
• Automating Manual Processes: Reducing time spent on tasks like data entry, reconciliations, and journal entries.
• Scaling Operations: Supporting growth, such as new business units, multi-entity consolidations, or global expansion.
• Enhancing Compliance: Meeting regulatory standards like SOX, IFRS, or GAAP.
• Shortening Financial Close Cycles: Accelerating the month-end or year-end close process.

3. Project Scope & Key Timelines

Provide a clear, realistic timeline. This signals to vendors that you have a serious, well-planned project and helps them allocate resources.

• RFI Issue Date: [Date]
• Vendor Q&A Deadline: [Date]
• RFI Response Due Date: [Date]
• Vendor Demo & Shortlist Period: [Date Range]
• Anticipated RFP Release: [Date]
• Target Contract & Go-Live Date: [Date]

Crafting Your RFI: The Ultimate Checklist of Key Sections

This is the core of your document. Structure your questions to be clear and focused on your most important requirements.

Core Financial Functionality

Ask vendors to detail how their solution addresses fundamental finance operations.

• General Ledger (GL): How flexible is the chart of accounts? Does it support custom dimensions or tags for reporting?
• Budgeting & Forecasting: What tools are available for creating, managing, and comparing budgets vs. actuals?
• Financial Consolidation: Describe the process for multi-entity and multi-currency consolidations.
• Close Management: How does the platform automate and streamline the financial close process?
• Dashboards & Analytics: What standard reports and customizable dashboards are included?
• Internal Controls: Explain the features for enforcing segregation of duties and creating audit trails.

Integration & Data Management

Seamless data flow is non-negotiable. Evaluate the platform’s ability to connect with your existing ecosystem.

• API & Connectivity: Does the solution offer a robust, well-documented API? What pre-built connectors (e.g., for ERP, CRM, payroll) are available?
• Data Migration: What tools, methodologies, and support do you provide for migrating historical data from our legacy systems?
• Data Formats: What file formats (e.g., CSV, XML, OFX) does the platform support for imports and exports?

Security, Compliance & Audit

For finance teams, security isn't just a feature—it's a prerequisite.

• Data Security: How is data protected both at rest and in transit (e.g., encryption standards)?
• Access Control: Describe your role-based access control (RBAC) capabilities.
• Regulatory Compliance: How does your software support standards relevant to our business (e.g., SOX, IFRS, GAAP)?
• Audit Trails: Is a comprehensive, immutable audit log of all system activity available for review?

Implementation, Training & Support

A great product with poor support is a failed investment. Gauge the vendor’s long-term partnership potential.

• Deployment Model: Is the solution cloud-native (multi-tenant SaaS), single-tenant, on-premises, or hybrid?
• Implementation Process: Detail your typical implementation timeline, milestones, and methodology.
• User Training: What training resources are provided for end-users and system administrators?
• Customer Support: Describe your support tiers, Service Level Agreements (SLAs), and the upgrade process.

Evaluating Vendors: Submission & Beyond

To make comparing responses easier, be clear about your process.

• Submission Instructions: Specify the response format (e.g., Word document, structured spreadsheet), the submission deadline, and the primary point of contact.
• Evaluation Criteria: Briefly mention how you will weigh responses (e.g., functional fit, technical architecture, vendor experience, estimated cost).
• Vendor Experience & References: Ask for case studies or client references from companies of a similar size, industry, and complexity. This provides crucial social proof of their ability to deliver.

RFI Best Practices & Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• DO: Focus on strategic goals rather than an exhaustive list of minor features.
• DO: Keep the format simple and easy for vendors to complete and for you to compare.
• DO: Allow vendors adequate time to provide thoughtful, high-quality responses.
• DON'T: Make it overly technical. The RFI is for strategic alignment; deep technical dives can wait for the RFP stage.
• DON'T: Ask for firm pricing. Request budgetary estimates or licensing models instead.
• DON'T: Ignore vendor questions. A Q&A period shows you're a collaborative partner.

For Vendors: A Step-by-Step Guide to Responding to a Finance RFI/RFP

Responding to a well-crafted RFI or RFP is your chance to stand out. A generic, copy-pasted response will quickly be set aside. Follow these steps to craft a reply that gets you on the shortlist.

Step 1: Deconstruct the RequestBefore writing a single word, thoroughly analyze the document. Identify the prospect’s core business drivers and pain points. Note all deadlines, formatting requirements, and mandatory ("must-have") features. This initial analysis is crucial for tailoring your response.

Step 2: Make a "Go/No-Go" DecisionBe honest: Is this opportunity a good fit for your solution? Compare the prospect’s company profile (industry, size, geography, technical needs) to your ideal customer profile. If you can't genuinely solve their primary challenges, it's better to politely decline than to waste resources on a poor fit.

Step 3: Answer with a Customer-Centric MindsetDon't just list features. Frame your answers around their needs. Instead of saying, "We offer automated consolidation," say, "Our automated consolidation engine will help you solve your stated goal of reducing your multi-entity close cycle from 10 days to 3." Connect every capability back to a benefit that solves their problem.

Step 4: Be Direct and HonestAnswer every question clearly. If your software doesn’t meet a specific requirement, say so. Honesty builds trust. If a feature is on your near-term roadmap, you can state that, but be transparent about its availability. Avoid vague marketing language.

Step 5: Provide Relevant ProofThis is where you differentiate yourself. Go beyond simple answers by providing social proof and evidence.

• Include a short case study from a similar client.
• Add screenshots of the specific dashboards or reports they asked about.
• Link to relevant security documentation or technical whitepapers.

Step 6: Polish and Professionally FormatYour response is a reflection of your company’s professionalism.

• Proofread it meticulously to eliminate any typos or errors.
• Ensure it adheres strictly to the requested format (e.g., spreadsheet, document).
• Create a compelling executive summary that quickly summarizes why you are the best partner for them.
• Submit your response on time, or even a day early, to show you are organized and eager.

Next Steps: After the RFI Responses Are In

Once you've received the RFI responses, your work continues. The typical next steps are:

1. Review and Score: Evaluate all responses against your predefined criteria.
2. Create a Shortlist: Select the top 3-5 vendors that best align with your needs.
3. Schedule Demos: Invite shortlisted vendors to provide a tailored demonstration of their software.
4. Issue an RFP: Send a more detailed Request for Proposal to your final candidates to get granular details on features, implementation, and pricing.
5. Final Selection: Conduct final negotiations and select your new finance software partner.

By following this guide, your finance software RFI will serve as a strategic roadmap, guiding you toward a solution that empowers your team and drives your business forward.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) about Finance Software RFIs

What is the difference between an RFI and an RFP for finance software?

‍An RFI (Request for Information) is a preliminary document used to gather broad information and shortlist vendors. An RFP (Request for Proposal) is a much more detailed document sent to the shortlisted vendors, asking for specific proposals on how they will meet your requirements, including firm pricing.

How long should our finance software RFI be?

‍Keep it concise. A typical RFI is 5-15 pages long. The goal is to get enough information to create a shortlist, not to document every single requirement. Focus on the questions that matter most to your decision.

What are the biggest mistakes to avoid when writing an RFI?

‍The biggest mistakes are being too vague about your objectives, asking for too much granular detail too early, and not providing enough context about your company. This leads to generic responses that are difficult to compare.

Should we include pricing questions in our RFI?

‍It's best to ask for general pricing models or budgetary estimates rather than a formal quote. Ask about their licensing structure (e.g., per-user, usage-based) to understand the potential total cost of ownership. Firm quotes are better suited for the RFP stage.

‍