How to Win Your Next Insurance Partnership: A Complete RFI Guide

Navigating the insurance marketplace can be a complex undertaking. For organizations looking to secure the best possible coverage and service, the Request for Information (RFI) is a critical first step in the procurement process. It’s a powerful tool for gathering data, understanding market capabilities, and shortlisting potential partners. But its effectiveness hinges on a clear, structured, and transparent approach from both sides of the table.

This guide provides a comprehensive, dual-sided framework for your next insurance RFI, ensuring that evaluators ask the right questions and responders provide the most impactful answers. Whether you're reviewing your current policy, exploring new vendors, or undergoing a complete risk management overhaul, this blueprint will help you build a foundation for a successful partnership.

1. Executive Summary / Introduction

• For the Evaluator (The Buyer): Start your RFI with a concise introduction. Clearly state your organization's name, the primary purpose of the RFI (e.g., "to identify potential partners for our corporate property and casualty insurance program"), and the general context. Are you a rapidly growing tech firm? A stable manufacturing company? This context helps responders tailor their answers. Keep it high-level but informative.
• For the Responder (The Broker/Carrier): Your executive summary is your first impression. Acknowledge your understanding of the evaluator's goals. Confirm your intent to participate in the RFI process and briefly state why your firm is a strong candidate. This isn't the place for a hard sell, but rather a confident and professional opening that shows you've read and understood the request.

2. Organizational Background & Project Scope

• For the Evaluator: Provide a clear picture of your organization. Include your industry, the approximate number of employees, your geographic footprint (local, national, or global), and a summary of your current or anticipated insurance needs. The more specific you are about the scope (e.g., "We are seeking a broker to manage our entire benefits portfolio for 500 U.S.-based employees"), the more relevant the responses will be.
• For the Responder: This is where you demonstrate your relevance. Don't just list your services; connect them directly to the evaluator's context. Highlight your experience with clients of a similar size, industry, or geographic scope. Mentioning a brief, anonymized success story (e.g., "We helped a 1,000-employee manufacturing client reduce their workers' compensation claims by 15% through our proactive safety program") can be incredibly effective.

3. RFI Objectives

• For the Evaluator: Be explicit about what you want to learn. Are you focused on finding the most innovative technology solutions? The most robust compliance and support structure? Or are you primarily concerned with cost-efficiency? Listing 3-5 key objectives (e.g., "Assess vendor capabilities in cyber liability risk mitigation") will guide responders to focus on what matters most to you.
• For the Responder: Structure your response to directly address each of the evaluator's stated objectives. Use their language. If they want to know about innovation, lead with your forward-thinking initiatives and technological differentiators. This shows you are not just responding, but listening.

4. Vendor Profile & Financial Standing

• For the Evaluator: This section is about due diligence. Request fundamental information about the vendor's business, including their company history, ownership structure, size, and key leadership. Crucially, ask for proof of their financial stability and their own insurance coverage, such as Errors & Omissions (E&O) and liability policies.
• For the Responder: Make this easy for the evaluator. Provide a clean, well-organized "fact sheet" with the requested information. Include professional biographies for the key team members who would be assigned to the account. Attaching financial reports (if public) and current certificates of insurance is standard practice and demonstrates transparency.

5. Insurance Products & Service Capabilities

• For the Evaluator: List the specific lines of coverage or services you are seeking. This could range from group health and dental to specialized policies like cyber insurance, directors and officers (D&O), or commercial auto liability. Ask about their ability to customize policies to fit your unique risk profile.
• For the Responder: Create a clear map between your products and the evaluator's needs. For each requested line of coverage, detail the key features, benefits, typical exclusions, and options for customization. Avoid jargon where possible, and focus on how your offerings solve the client's problems.

6. Claims Management & Client Support

• For the Evaluator: This is where the rubber meets the road. Ask pointed questions about their claims process. What are their average turnaround times? What is the structure of their adjuster network? What digital tools are available for clients to report and track claims? Inquire about their client advocacy and support models. Who is your day-to-day contact? What is the escalation path for issues?
• For the Responder: Detail your claims process with clarity. Provide any available Service Level Agreements (SLAs). Showcase your client support structure with an organizational chart if helpful. Highlight any client success metrics, such as client retention rates or satisfaction scores (e.g., Net Promoter Score).

7. Technology & Integration Readiness

• For the Evaluator: In today's digital world, technology is key. Inquire about their client-facing platforms, online portals for benefits administration or risk management, and their reporting and analytics capabilities. Ask about their experience with Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) or Application Programming Interface (API) integrations with HRIS or payroll systems.
• For the Responder: Show, don't just tell. Include screenshots of your digital platforms. Provide sample reports or workflow diagrams. If you have a history of successful integrations with common client systems (like Workday, ADP, or Oracle), mention them. This demonstrates technical competence and a commitment to a seamless client experience.

8. Compliance, Licensing, & Regulatory Capabilities

• For the Evaluator: This is a non-negotiable area. Request proof of all necessary state and federal licenses. Ask about their data security and privacy protocols. Inquire about their approach to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) within their own organization and in their service delivery.
• For the Responder: Provide copies of all relevant licenses and certifications. If you have undergone third-party security audits like SOC 2 or are certified under standards like ISO 27001, highlight this prominently. It’s a powerful differentiator that signals a mature and secure operation.

9. References & Past Performance

• For the Evaluator: Ask for at least three client references, preferably from organizations that are similar to yours. Request that they include metrics or specific outcomes that demonstrate success.
• For the Responder: Choose your references wisely. Always ask your clients for permission before listing them. Provide a brief case study for each reference that outlines the challenge, your solution, and the positive outcome, supported by quantifiable metrics. Including client logos (with permission) can add visual credibility.

10. Submission Requirements & Format

• For the Evaluator: To make the evaluation process manageable and fair, provide a standardized format for responses. This could be a fillable Word document, a structured Excel scorecard, or a specific online portal. Clearly state the submission deadline, time zone, and the single point of contact for all questions.
• For the Responder: Acknowledge and confirm that you will adhere to the requested format. If any part of the required format is unclear, do not hesitate to ask for clarification. This is preferable to submitting an incorrect or incomplete response.

11. Evaluation Criteria & Q&A Protocol

• For the Evaluator: Transparency is key to building trust. Outline the criteria you will use to score the RFI responses and, if possible, provide weightings. For example: Financial Stability (20%), Product Fit (30%), Client Support (25%), Technology (25%). Also, define the protocol for questions—will there be a set period for written questions, followed by a public Q&A document for all participants?
• For the Responder: Use the evaluation criteria as a guide for structuring your entire response. If you see that "Technology" is weighted heavily, ensure your section on technology is exceptionally detailed and compelling. Mirroring their priorities in your response shows you are aligned with their vision of a successful partnership.

12. Post-RFI Process & Next Steps

• For the Evaluator: Manage expectations by providing a clear timeline for what happens after the RFI submission deadline. When do you anticipate making a decision on who to invite to the next stage (e.g., a formal Request for Proposal - RFP)? When might demos or in-person interviews take place?
• For the Responder: Conclude your RFI response by confirming your availability for any follow-up activities. You can proactively offer to provide a live demo of your technology platform or make key team members available for an introductory call. This shows enthusiasm and a willingness to engage further.

By approaching the insurance RFI as a structured, two-way dialogue, both buyers and potential partners can save time, reduce friction, and lay the groundwork for a transparent and productive relationship. A well-crafted RFI doesn't just solicit information; it builds the foundation for a partnership built on clarity and mutual understanding.

‍