AutoRFP vs Arphie vs HeyIris (2026): Best AI Tool for Security Questionnaires?

AutoRFP vs Arphie vs HeyIris is a comparison of three AI-native tools, so the usual legacy-vs-AI debate doesn't apply. What separates them is how each one handles security questionnaires and due diligence questionnaires (DDQs): where answers come from, how evidence is attached, and how responses get back into the buyer's portal. Inventive AI is an AI-native RFP platform that drafts cited answers from your connected company knowledge and flags conflicting or outdated content before it reaches a buyer.
Key takeaways
- AutoRFP is the most predictable buy: published plan prices, unlimited users, ISO 27001, and a Portal Agent for Ariba, Workday, and Coupa.
- Arphie is the most transparent drafter: every answer shows its exact source, a confidence score, and the AI's reasoning, drawn from live connected systems.
- HeyIris is built around your security posture: it attaches the latest evidence to each answer, connects to Drata and Vanta, and includes unlimited questionnaires per paid seat.
- Inventive AI adds the check none of them lead with: it flags contradictions between your own source documents before they reach a buyer, at $830/month, billed annually, with unlimited users.
AutoRFP vs Arphie vs HeyIris at a glance
Checked against each vendor's own pricing, security, and product pages and G2 in November 2026.
What should a security team test in AutoRFP, Arphie, and HeyIris?
Run a real questionnaire through each tool and test the parts that go wrong after go-live.
- The format test: load a CAIQ or SIG export and one custom buyer spreadsheet, then check that answers return in the original format.
- The evidence test: ask for a current SOC 2 report or policy, and see which tool attaches the latest version automatically.
- The stale-control test: change one control in your source content, then check which tool reflects it in the next draft.
- The gap test: include five questions your content doesn't cover, and see which tool flags them.
- The portal test: submit one questionnaire through the portal your biggest buyer uses.
- The contributor count: count every security, legal, and engineering reviewer who needs access, and price that number.
How do AutoRFP, Arphie, and HeyIris ground security answers?
All three draft only from content you approve and cite their sources. They differ in where that content lives and how much of the AI's thinking reviewers can see.
- AutoRFP: drafts from approved content synced daily from your existing systems. Each answer gets a Trust Score for its sources and a Feedback Score for how fully it answers the question. Web research is a separate path that a user switches on.
- Arphie: drafts from approved Q&A and live connections to Google Drive, SharePoint, Confluence, Notion, Seismic, and Highspot. Each answer shows its exact source, a confidence score, and the reasoning behind it.
- HeyIris: drafts from a knowledge map of your approved documents and security posture, with a passage-level citation and confidence score on every answer.
Which handles security evidence best: AutoRFP, Arphie, or HeyIris?
HeyIris goes furthest on evidence, while AutoRFP offers buyers the most self-service.
- HeyIris: finds the latest version of a policy or report and attaches it to the answer, then carries it through the export. It connects to Drata and Vanta for current compliance data.
- AutoRFP: a self-service Trust Center lets buyers pull reports and agreements without a separate request.
- Arphie: pulls the latest compliance evidence and control materials through its Vanta integration, keeps answers current through live source connections, and flags answers that may be outdated when documents change, with Smart Merge flagging overlapping entries.
Which fills procurement portals best: AutoRFP, Arphie, or HeyIris?
AutoRFP has the most specific portal coverage of the three.
- AutoRFP: its Portal Agent pulls questions out of Ariba, Workday, and Coupa into the platform.
- HeyIris: a Chrome extension fills answers inside web portals without copy and paste.
- Arphie: imports and exports Word and Excel files and offers a browser extension, but doesn't name portal integrations, and a few G2 reviewers mention export issues.
Infographic 2 brief: Takeaway headline: Who pays for growth? Three bars showing what raises the bill: AutoRFP (more projects), Arphie (custom quote), HeyIris (more paid seats). Note that AutoRFP and HeyIris both include unlimited collaborators. Alt text: AutoRFP vs Arphie vs HeyIris pricing models.
How do AutoRFP, Arphie, and HeyIris pricing compare?
Only AutoRFP publishes prices. HeyIris prices per active user, and Arphie quotes each customer.
- AutoRFP: AutoRFP pricing is published. Scale costs $899/month for 24 projects a year and Accelerate $1,299/month for 50, billed annually, with unlimited users.
- HeyIris: HeyIris pricing is per active user, with unlimited RFPs, proposals, DDQs, and security questionnaires per seat, plus SSO, SAML, SCIM, a dedicated CSM, implementation, and MCP access on every plan.
- Arphie: Arphie pricing is a custom quote, and Arphie's own comparison lists no published price or discount schedule.
The right model depends on what grows fastest for you. A small security team with heavy volume suits per-seat pricing, while a broad team with moderate volume suits per-project pricing.
How do AutoRFP, Arphie, and HeyIris compare head to head?
AutoRFP vs Arphie: which is better?
AutoRFP fits teams that want predictable pricing and portal automation. Arphie fits teams whose reviewers want to see the AI's reasoning.
- Transparency: Arphie shows reasoning on every answer. AutoRFP shows a Trust Score and a Feedback Score.
- Portals: AutoRFP covers Ariba, Workday, and Coupa. Arphie doesn't name portal integrations.
- Rollout: Arphie says it usually migrates teams in under a week. AutoRFP offers a free two-week proof of concept.
AutoRFP vs HeyIris: which is better?
AutoRFP fits broad teams with moderate volume. HeyIris fits small security teams with heavy volume.
- Pricing: AutoRFP caps projects and includes every user. HeyIris includes unlimited questionnaires per paid seat.
- Evidence: HeyIris attaches the latest evidence to each answer. AutoRFP offers buyers a Trust Center.
- Certifications: AutoRFP publishes ISO 27001 and regional hosting in the US, EU, and AU.
Arphie vs HeyIris: which is better?
Both draft from live, approved knowledge with citations. Arphie leans toward answer transparency, and HeyIris toward security evidence and deal context.
- Arphie: shows the AI's reasoning, merges duplicate content, and connects to sales enablement tools like Seismic and Highspot.
- HeyIris: connects to Drata and Vanta, scores go/no-go fit, and pulls deal context from Gong and Salesforce.
- Shared trade-off: both are quote-only, and both have smaller G2 review bases than older tools.
Is there an alternative that catches contradictions in your security content?
Yes. Inventive AI is an AI-native RFP platform that drafts cited answers from your connected company knowledge and flags conflicting or outdated content before it reaches a buyer. Security documentation often differs across teams, and Inventive AI catches those contradictions before one ends up in a questionnaire.
Best features
- Conflict detection: the AI Content Manager flags contradictions, duplicates, and outdated content across SharePoint, Google Drive, Confluence, and Notion. G2 reviewers on security teams call this out specifically.
- Answers you can verify: each AI-drafted answer cites the exact passage with a 0 to 100% confidence score, and gaps are flagged for an expert instead of guessed.
- Questionnaires and portals: writes answers back into the original Excel file, fills Coupa, Ariba, and Jaggaer through Portal Answers, and uses a browser extension for other vendor portals.
Limitations
- Analytics: reporting and dashboards are the most common G2 request.
- Review controls: some security reviewers want more detailed approval workflow controls.
Pricing: $830/month, billed annually, with unlimited users.
G2 rating: 4.9 out of 5 from 88 reviews, and rated #1 Easiest to Use in G2's RFP category.
Proof: Druva runs about 600 RFPs and security questionnaires a year on Inventive AI, and Ripple chose it over AutoRFP after a head-to-head pilot.
What do G2 reviewers say about AutoRFP, Arphie, and HeyIris?
AutoRFP vs Arphie vs HeyIris: which should you choose?
Pick by what slows your security questionnaires down most.
- Portal submissions and budget certainty: AutoRFP, with its Portal Agent and published prices. Teams outgrowing project caps can compare AutoRFP alternatives.
- Reviewers who need to see the AI's reasoning: Arphie. Teams that need stronger portal handling can compare Arphie alternatives.
- Evidence attached to every answer, with heavy volume on a small team: HeyIris.
- Security content that disagrees across teams: Inventive AI, which flags the contradictions before they reach a buyer.







.png)